3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
Excellent
dictionary with excellent definitions, May 1, 2004
Reviewer: A reader
Things I like about the dictionary:
*Excellent definitions (the definitions in this book are some of the
best I've read; they are accurate and really give the student a sense of
what the particular Chinese word/character means)
*Example sentences/phrases with Pinyin (unlike the Concise
English-Chinese Chinese-English Dictionary (ISBN 0195911512) which does
NOT have Pinyin for its example sentences/phrases, this one does, with
English translation as well; this if very helpful when one wants to see
how the character/word is used)
*Comprehensive (according to the dictionary itself, the work contain
over 10,000 characters; but this is not for the scholar of Chinese, for
as the preface states, "The dictionary is a small-sized reference book
for learning Chinese, chiefly for teachers and students in primary
schools and middle schools, and for intermediate-educated readers as
well.")
*The original Chinese text is included (this is actually a
translation of an actual Chinese dictionary)
Things I don't like about this book:
*All the definitions under the head character is in one paragraph
(unlike the Concise English-Chinese Chinese-English Dictionary (ISBN
0195911512) which list each character combinations of a particular
character on separate line, this dictionary does not. Thus, all the
information is in one paragraph, making it rather difficult to find the
character combination (i.e., the word) one is looking for)
*Lack of some character combination (perhaps because the book is a
translation of an actual Chinese dictionary, it does not include some
important character combinations; this is very unfortunate, for it is an
excellent dictionary overall)
This dictionary and the Concise English-Chinese Chinese-English
Dictionary (ISBN 0195911512) are an excellent combination. |